Theory Case Studies Resources Blog FAQ About Services Mailing List Contact
 

The Case: The Supposedly Invisible Man
Jack was one serious physicist, making breakthrough after breakthrough. So why did everyone try to sabotage him, and why didn't he get promoted?
The Players
Jack, a 52 year old physicist and network engineer.

Various bosses and co-workers, inside and outside his department, from higher to far lower levels.
The Problem
Jack fancied himself Albert Einstein – and he was nearly as brilliant! His company’s mission was leading-edge networking software, and he generated critical ideas over 15 years, many of which found their way into important products. Even so, he was marginalized and scapegoated in the organization, given bad reviews (which said nothing useful about what the problems were) and few raises, resulting in his becoming angry and dysfunctional. It wouldn't be long before he was fired or forced to leave.

The main problem was that Jack had absolutely no awareness of how he came across to other people. Specifically, he had no understanding that he seemed both belittling and out of contact; both nasty and a “space shot” – a combination guaranteed to lead to his being pilloried. But Jack lived in the world of mathematical theory, and believed that since he was superior in that world, he simply didn't have to pay attention to everyday relationships. He looked at “normal” people with scorn, though it quickly became clear that he also envied them. He was humble in describing his accomplishments, but it was obvious that he came across to others as arrogant.
The Smart Relationship Insight
Jack needed to read himself right! While he seemed vastly insensitive, it was a protective cover for similarly vast insecurity. He was the oddly brilliant son of a Kentucky coal miner who had been furious at his company, which had abused it's workers and ultimately hastened his death. Jack had inherited similar attitudes, which now, in a vastly different context and with the added factor of his intellectual brilliance, appeared as paranoia and blindness to the world around him. We shared the pun that he wouldn't be able to get into his mind before he got out out of his mine. Gradually, he came to understand how he had transferred his father’s work issues to himself and his own prestigious company, decades later and wholly inappropriately.

Jack quickly took to the idea of learning to see himself objectively. He had his wife videotape him at parties and other gatherings, and recorded himself giving lectures and chairing meetings at work. He practiced speaking into a tape recorder on his commute. He even installed a three-way mirror in his bathroom.

Using these feedback devices, Jack came to see what other people saw in him, and why they had disliked him. He was astonished and abashed, but didn't run away. He became so good at seeing and hearing himself in context that he could process other people's reactions to him in “real time,” an ability few possess.

He used this new skill set to change his way with his colleagues. His tone of voice changed to one that sounded involved, cooperative, and down to earth. His appearance changed from “shaggy-professorial” to “scientist-managerial’, which fit his goals more closely. He became easy going and cordial with colleagues, yet was able to display his strength and defend his intellectual turf where necessary. Previously people had denigrated his ideas, then appropriated them as their own.

The changes extended to the politics of his company. While before he had been deaf to its Machiavellian workings, he now developed super-acute hearing. He implemented a program of building strategic alliances, and chose projects that would keep him close to colleagues who could help him if the higher-ups decided to back someone else, or fire someone because of a funding cut. He learned the value of naming strategic colleagues as second authors of his papers. He aligned his research interests far more closely with those of the company, without sacrificing either his interest in or the quality of, his work. He no longer worked in a vacuum; instead, he constantly kept in mind the company’s needs five years out. This made the higher-ups realize his tangible strategic value.
Outcome
A few years out, Jack has had a promotion and pay increase, and is no longer marginalized. The old “scape-goating days” are all but forgotten. He is working harder then ever, but productively and with results. He is being taken seriously both by his peers and by corporate management. He has bypassed the people who were (in fact!) out to get him (some of them are the new scapegoats), and now counts as his friends several people at the vice-presidential level. He may well become one of them.

There was another spin-off: Jack’s family life improved! While he still tends to “have his feet in the living room and his head in the clouds” (to quote his wife) he is far more attentive and involved with her and his three sons. Jack’s recent comment: “thank God I finally realized we're all here together.”

All this from understanding that people read us constantly, so we had better learn to see ourselves as they see us!
 

Copyright © 2005 Richard Pomerance